Full text of Human Rights Record of the US in 2004
Following is the full text of the Human Rights Record of the
United States in 2004, released by the Information office of
China's State Council Thursday, March 3, 2005.
The Human Rights
Record of the United States in 2004
By
the Information Office of the State Council of the People's Republic
of China
March 3, 2005
In
2004 the atrocity of US troops abusing
Iraqi POWs exposed the dark side of human rights performance of
the United States. The scandal shocked the humanity and was condemned
by the international community. It is quite ironic that on Feb. 28 of
this year, the State Department of the United States once again posed
as the "the world human rights police" and released its Country
Reports on Human Rights Practices for 2004. As in previous
years, the reports pointed fingers at human rights situation in more
than 190 countries and regions (including China) but kept silent on
the US misdeeds in this field. Therefore, the world people have to
probe the human rights record behind the Statue of Liberty in the
United States.
I. On Life,
Liberty and Security of Person
American society is characterized with rampant violent crimes, severe
infringement of people's rights by law enforcement departments and
lack of guarantee for people's rights to life, liberty and security of
person.
Violent crimes pose a serious threat to people's lives. According to a
report released by the Department of Justice of the United States on
Nov. 29, 2004, in 2003 residents aged 12 and above in the United
States experienced about 24 million victimizations, and there occurred
1,381,259 murders, robberies and other violent crimes, averaging 475
cases per 100,000 people. Among them there were 16,503 homicides, up
1.7 percent over 2002, or nearly six cases in every 100,000 residents,
and one of every 44 Americans aged above 12 was victimized.
The Associated Press reported on June 24, 2004 that the number of
violent crimes in many US cities were on the rise. In 2003 Chicago
alone recorded 598 homicides, 80 percent of which involved the use of
guns. The Washington D.C. reported 41,738 murders, robberies and other
violent crimes in 2003, averaging 6,406.4 cases per 100,000 residents.
In 2004 the District recorded 198 killings, or a homicide rate of 35
per 100,000 residents. Detroit,which has less than 1 million
residents, recorded 18,724 criminal cases in 2003, including 366
murders and 814 rapes, which amounted to a homicide rate of 41 per
100,000 residents.
In
2003 the homicide rate in Baltimore was 43 per 100,000 residents. The
Baltimore Sun reported on Dec. 17, 2004 that the city reported 271
killings from January to early December in 2004.
It
was reported that on Sept. 8, 2004 that by Sept. 4, 2004 there had
been 368 homicides in the city, up 4.2 percent year-on-year. The USA
Today reported on July 16, 2004 that in an average week in the US
workplace one employee is killed and at least 25 are seriously injured
in violent assaults by current or former co-workers. The Cincinnati
Post reported on Nov. 12, 2004 that homicides average 17 a week and
there are nearly 5,500 violent
assaults a day at US job sites.
The United States has the biggest number of gun owners and gun
violence has affected lots of innocent lives. According to a survey
released by the University of Chicago in 2001, 41.7 percent
of
men and 28.5 percent of women in the United States report having a gun
in their homes, and 29.2 percent of men and 10.2 percent of women
personally own a gun. The Los Angeles Times reported on Jul. 19, 2004
that since 2000 the number of firearm holders rose 28 percent in
California.
About 31,000 Americans are killed and 75,000 wounded by firearms each
year, which means more than 80 people are shot dead each day. In 2002
there were 30,242 firearm killings in the United States; 54 percent of
all suicides and 67 percent of all homicides were related to the use
of firearms. The Associated Press reported that 808 people were shot
dead in the first half of 2004 in Detroit.
Police violence and infringement of human rights by law enforcement
agencies also constitute a serious problem. At present, 5,000 law
enforcement agencies in the United States use TASER - a kind of
electric shock gun, which sends out 50,000 volts of impulse voltage
after hitting the target. Since 1999, more than 80 people died from
TASER shootings, 60 percent of which occurred between November 2003
and November 2004.
A
survey found that in the 17 years from 1985 to 2002, Los Angeles
recorded more than 100 times increase in police shooting at automobile
drivers, killing at least 25 and injuring more than 30 of them. Of
these cases, 90 percent were due to misjudgment. (The Los Angeles
Times, Feb. 29, 2004.)
On
Jul. 21, 2004 Chinese citizen Zhao Yan was handcuffed and severely
beaten while she was in the United States on a normal business trip.
She suffered injuries in many parts of her body and serious mental
harm.
The New York Times reported on Apr. 19, 2004 a comprehensive study of
328 criminal cases over the last 15 years in which the convicted
person was exonerated suggests that there are thousands of innocent
people in prison today. The study identified 199 murder exoneration,
73 of them in capital cases. In more than half of the cases, the
defendants had been in prison for more than 10 years.
The United States characterizes itself as "a paradise for free
people," but the ratio of its citizens deprived of freedom has
remained among the highest in the world. Statistics released by the
Federal Bureau of Investigation last November showed that the nation
made an estimated 13.6 million arrests in 2003. The national arrest
rate was 4,695.1 arrests per 100,000 people, 0.2 percent up than that
of the previous year (USA Today, Nov. 8, 2004).
According to statistics from the Department of Justice, the number of
inmates in the United States jumped from 320,000 in 1980 to 2 million
in 2000, a hike by six times. From 1995 to 2003, the number of inmates
grew at an annual rate of 3.5 percent in the country, where one out of
every 142 people is behind bars. The number of convicted offenders may
total more than 6 million if parolees and probationers are also
counted. The Chicago Tribune reported on Nov. 8 last year that the
federal and state prison population amounted to 1.47 million last
year, 2.1 percent more than in 2003. The number of criminals rose by
over 5 percent in 11 states, with the growth in North Dakota up by
11.4 percent and in Minnesota by 10.3 percent.
Most prisons in the United States are overcrowded, but still cannot
meet the demand. The country has spent an average of 7 billion US
dollars a year building new jails and prisons in the past 10 years.
California has seen only one college but 21 new prisons built since
1984.
Jails have become one of the huge and most lucrative industries, with
a combined staff of more than 530,000 and being the second largest
employer in the United States only after the General Motors. Private
prisons are more and more common. The country now has over 100 private
prisons in 27 states and 18 private prison companies. The value of
goods and services created by inmates surged from 400 million US
dollars in 1980 to 1.1 billion US dollars in 1994. Abuse of prisoners
and violence occur frequently in US jails and prisons, which are under
disorderly management. The Los Angeles Times reported on Aug. 15 last
year that over 40 state prison systems were once under some form of
court order, for brutality, crowding, poor food and lack of medical
care.
The NewsWeek of the United States also reported last May that in
Pennsylvania, Arizona and some other states, inmates are routinely
stripped in front of others before being moved to a new prison or a
new unit within their prison. Male inmates are often made to wear
women's pink underwear as a form of humiliation. New inmates are
frequently beaten and cursed at and sometimes made to crawl.
At
a jail in New York City, some guards bump prisoners against the walls,
pinch their arms and wrists, and force them to receive insulting
checks nakedly. Some male inmates are sometimes compelled to stand in
the nude before a group of women guards. Some female inmates go in
shackles to hospital for treatment and nursing after they get ill or
pregnant, some give births without a midwife, and some are locked to
sickbeds with fetters after Caesarean operation.
Over 80,000 women prisoners in the United States are mothers, and the
overall number of the minor children of the American women prisoners
is estimated at some 200,000. The country had more than 3,000 pregnant
women in jails from 2000 to 2003 and 3,000 babies were born to the
prisoners during this period (see
Mexico's Milenio on Feb. 21, 2004). It is estimated that at least
more than 40,000 prisoners are locked up in the so-called "super
jails", where the prisoner is confined to a very tiny cell, cannot see
other people throughout the year, and has only one hour out for
exercise every day.
Sexual harassment and encroachment are common in jails in the Unite
States. The New York Times reported last October that at least 13
percent of inmates in the country are sexually assaulted in prison
(Ex-Inmate's Suit Offers View Into Sexual Slavery in Prisons, The New
York Times, Oct. 12, 2004). In jails of seven central and western US
states, 21 percent of the inmates suffer sexual abuse at least once
after being put in prison. The ratio is higher among women inmates,
with nearly one fourth of them sexually assaulted by jail guards.
II. On Political
Rights and Freedom
The United States claims to be "a paragon of democracy," but American
democracy is manipulated by the rich and malpractices are common.
Elections in the United States are in fact a contest of money. The
presidential and Congressional elections last year cost nearly 4
billion US dollars, some 1 billion US dollars or one third more than
that spent in the 2000 elections. The 2004 presidential election has
been listed as the most expensive campaign in the country's history
(see http://www.opensecrets.org/overview), with the cost jumping to
1.7 billion US dollars from 1 billion US dollars in 2000. To win the
election, the Democratic Party and Republican Party had to try their
utmost to raise funds.
The Washington Post reported on Dec. 3 last year that the Democratic
Party collected 389.8 million US dollars in electoral funds and the
Republican Party raised 385.3 million US dollars, both hitting a
record high (see Fundraising Records Broken by Both Major Political
Parties, Washington Post on Dec. 3, 2004).
Data released by the Federal Election Commission (FEC) on Dec. 14,
2004 show the average spending for Senate races was 2,518,750 US
dollars in 2004, with the highest reaching 31,488,821 US dollars; and
the average spending for House races was 511,043 US dollars (see
http://www.opensecrets.org/overview), with the highest reaching
9,043,293 US dollars (see http://www.opensecrets.org/overview/topraces.asp?cycle=2004).
The Republican Party, the Democratic Party and their periphery
organizations spent a total of 1.2 billion US dollars on TV
commercials, making this presidential election the most expensive in
history. The TV commercials were broadcast 750,000 times, twice of the
airings in the general election in 2000. In the Oct. 1 - 13 period in
2004, the Republican Party spent 14.5 million US dollars on
advertising, and the Democratic Party's advertising spending amounted
to 24 million US dollars in the first 20 days of October 2004.
In
the elections, political parties and interest groups not only donated
money for their favorite candidates, but also directly spent funds on
maximizing their influence upon the elections. In Maryland, some
corporate bosses donated as much as 130,000 US dollars. In return, the
candidates after being elected would serve the interests of big
political donators. The Baltimore Sun called this "Buying Power" (see
"Buying Power", The Baltimore Sun, April 5, 2004). Due to the fact
that local judges in 38 states need to be elected, quite a number of
candidates began campaign advertising and looking for big donators.
Some interest groups also got themselves involved in the judge
election campaign.The US election system has quite a few flaws. The
newly adopted Help America Vote Act of 2004 requires voters to offer a
series of documents such as a stable residence or identification in
registering, which in reality disenfranchises thousands of homeless
people.
The United States is the only country in the world that rules out
ex-inmates' right to vote, which disenfranchises 5 million ex-inmates
and 13 percent male black people (see Milenio, Mexico, Oct. 22 2004).
The 2004 US presidential election reported many problems, including
counting errors, machine malfunctions, registration confusion, legal
uncertainty, and lack of respect for voters. According to a report
carried by the USA Today on Dec. 28, 2004, due to counting errors, a
review of election results in 10 counties nationwide by the Scripps
Howard News Service found more than 12,000 ballots that weren't
counted in the presidential race, almost one in every 10 ballots cast
in those counties. Due to machine malfunctions, 92,000 ballots failed
to record a vote for president in Ohio alone. Registration confusion
made four fifths of the states go into the election without
computerized statewide voter databases (see "Election Day Leftovers",
USA Today, Dec. 28, 2004). The Democratic Party brought 35 lawsuits
against the Republican Party in at least 17 states, charging the
latter with threatening and blocking voters from registering or
voting, especially minority ethnic groups. In Florida, the cases of
black people being removed from voter registration list or their votes
being denied were 10 times higher than people of other races. The
British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) reported on Sept. 22, 2004 that
during the period of election, someone often distributed handbills to
black voters to bilk and intimidate them by saying that anyone who
defaulted electricity bills, apartment bills or parking fines would be
arrested outside the polling booths. Some others pretended to be
plainclothes outside polling booths and demanded voters show their
identifications. However, black people who were able to present photo
identification were less than one fifth of white people, therefore,
many of them were rejected.
In
the meantime, fabrications of disputable pictures and statements were
put in the agenda of political maneuvers. Campaign advertisement and
political debates were full of distorted facts, false information and
lies. According to statistics of the Annenberg Public Policy Center of
University of Pennsylvania, campaign advertisement for the 2004 US
presidential election had a large proportion of false information that
was enough to mislead voters, far beyond 50 percent in 1996. In the
Republican camp, at least 75 percent contained untrue information and
personal attacks. The website of the center (http://www.FactCheck.org)
listed at least 100 items of such information.
The US freedom of the press is filled with hypocrisy. Power and
intimidation hang over the halo of press freedom. The New York Times
published a commentary on March 30, 2004, saying that the US
government's reliance on slandering had reached an unprecedented level
in contemporary American political history, and the government
prepared to abuse power at any moment to threat potential critics.
A
collected works, Zensor USA, revealed that whenever the faults of
government dignitaries or big companies were touched, the strong
American press censorship system would snap at the journalists who
insisted on investigation and made them the last sacrificial lamb.
(see Das Schweigen der Journalisten, Handelsblatt,
Germany, March 17, 2004).
The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) kept watch on a leader of
freedom of speech movement in University of California at Berkeley for
a decade long. Although no record showed he violated federal laws, the
FBI hired someone to keep monitoring his daily activities and collect
his personal information without permission from the court. (see
SingTao Daily, Oct. 11, 2004).
On
July 16, 2004 the US State Department made a regulation, in violation
of the norms of most other countries, that foreign reporters should
leave the country while waiting for the valid period of their visas to
be extended. The annual report of Native American Journalists
Association criticized the US administration for the move, which
severely infringes upon press freedom. (see AP story, Antigua,
Guatemala Oct. 24, 2004).
Someone with the American Society of Newspaper Editors said that the
US administration's measures reflected its repulsion of foreign news
media. (see Milenio, Mexico, June 20, 2004). In Iraq, the United
States on the one hand alleged that it had brought democracy to the
Iraqi people, on the other hand it suppressed public opinion. On March
28, 2004 US troops closed down a Shiite newspaper in Baghdad, which
triggered a protest demonstration by thousands of Iraqi people.
On
Sept. 27, the Association of American University Presses, Association
of American Publishers and other organizations jointly lodged a
complaint to the district court of Manhattan, New York, charging the
Office of Foreign Assets Control under the Department of the Treasury
with deliberately preventing literary works of
Iranian, Cuban and Sudanese writers from entering the United
States and turning the economic sanctions against the three countries
into a "censorship system" to stop free dissemination of information
and ideology. (see Xinhua story, Sept. 30, 2004).
In
another case, eight reporters, including Jim Taricani of the TV
station in Providence, Rhode Island with the National Broadcasting
Company (NBC), Judith Miller of The New York Times, and Matthew Cooper
of Time magazine, were declared guilty for they declined to disclose
the confidential sources of news. The New York Times pointed out on
Nov. 10, 2004 that through these cases, it was found out that press
freedom suffered rampant infringement.
In
addition, in recent years, over a dozen foreign journalists have been
detained in airports in the United States, including the one in Los
Angeles. In March 2003, a Danish press-photographer was expelled out
of the country after a DNA test. A Swiss journalist was rejected from
entry of an airport in Washington D.C. The airport staffs by force
took pictures and finger prints of the journalist. Meanwhile, he was
not permitted to contact the Swiss embassy in the Unite States. In
May, two groups of French journalists, altogether six members, were
rejected of entry the US territory. They simply came to the Unite
States to cover an exposition. Two Dutch journalists fell into trouble
when they were covering a film award ceremony. In October and
December, one British reporter and one
Austrian journalist were held up at US airports respectively. In
early May, 2004, a British female journalist, who was sent by The
Guardian to Los Angeles to cover some events, was detained at the Los
Angeles airport and faced interrogation and body search, and then was
handcuffed and taken to the detention house in the downtown. There,
she was detained for 26 hours before sent back to Britain.
III. On
Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
The United States refuses to ratify the International Covenant on
Economic, Social and Cultural rights and took negative attitude to the
economic, social and cultural rights of the laborers. Poverty, hunger
and homelessness have haunted the world richest country.
The population of people living in poverty has been on a steady rise.
According to a report by The Sun on July, 6, 2004, from 1970 to 2000
(adjusted for inflation), the bottom 90 percent's average income
stagnated while the top 10 percent experienced an average yearly
income increase of nearly 90 percent. Upper-middle-and-upper-class
families that constitute the top 10 percent of the income distribution
are prospering while many among the remaining 90 percent struggle to
maintain their standard of living. Worsening income disparities have
formed two Americas. (Two Americas, The Baltimore Sun, July 6, 2004).
According to a report of the Wall Street Journal on June 15, 2004, a
study on the fall of 2003 by Arthur Kennickell of the Board of
Governor of the Federal Reserve System showed that the nation's
wealthiest 1 percent owned 53 percent of all the stocks held by
families or individuals, and 64 percent of the bonds. They control
more than a third of the nation's wealth. ( US Led a Resurgence Last
Year Among Millionaires World-Wide, The Wall Street Journal, June 15,
2004). In Washington D.C., the top 20 percent of the city's households
have 31 times the average income of the 20 percent at the bottom.
(D.C. Gap in Wealth Growing, The Washington Post, July 22, 2004).
Since November 2003, the average income of most American families have
been on the decline. The earning of many medium and low-income
families could not keep up with the price rises. They could barely
handle the situation. According to the statistics released by the US
Census Bureau in 2004, the number of Americans in poverty has been
climbing for three years. It rose by 1.3 million year-on-year in 2003
to 35.9 million. The poverty rate in 2003 hit 12.5 percent, or one in
eight people, the highest since 1998. (Census: Poverty Rose By
Million, USA Today, August 27, 2004, More Americans Were Uninsured and
Poor in 2003, Census Finds, The New York Times, August 27, 2004).
The homeless population continues to rise nationwide. On Dec. 15,
2004, an annual survey report released at the US Conference of Mayors
showed that the number of people seeking emergency food aid increased
by 14 percent year-on-year while the number of people seeking
emergency shelter aid increased by 6 percent. (http://www.usmayors.org).
It is estimated that the homeless population reached 3.5 million in
the United States. But the US Federal budget has stopped providing
fund to build new affordable housing, which forced many local
governments to cut the public housing projects. The city of San Diego
has a homeless population of 8,000, but the government could only
provide 3,000 temporary beds. Those without lodging tickets are
regarded illegal to live on the streets. They would be summoned or
detained. In January 2004, an investigator with the US Commission on
Human Right denounced the US for large-scale infringement on human
rights on housing issue.
The health insurance crisis has become prominent. A report of the
Washington Post on Sept. 28, 2004 said health insurance costs posted
their fourth straight year of double-digit increases in 2004. Over the
past four years, health insurance costs have leaped 59 percent - about
five times faster than both wage growth and inflation. Around 14.3
million Americans put one fourth of their income on the health
expenses. (Higher Costs, Less Care, The Washington Post, September 28,
2004). Currently, family health insurance plan costs more than 10,000
US dollars each year. Many families could not afford it. Fewer workers
have coverage - 61 percent in 2004, compared with 65 percent in 2001.
(Health Plan Costs Jump 11%, The Washington Post, September 10, 2004)
Compared with 2003, the number of people without health insurance
increased 1.4 million to 45 million, or 15.6 percent of the country's
population. (Census: Poverty Rose by Million, USA Today, August 27,
2004). In Texas, about one fourth of the workers don't have health
insurance. (Spain
Uprising newspaper, May 11, 2004). In California, around 6 million
Californians don't have health insurance and the welfare system with
the annual cost of 60 billion US dollars are about to collapse. (The
Los Angeles Times, May 6, 2004). Meanwhile, medical accidents occurred
one after another, becoming the third killer following heart disease
and cancer. According to a report of Boston Globe on July 27, 2004,
one out of every 25 in-patients become the victim of medical accident.
From 2000 to 2002, 195,000 people died of medical accidents each year.
The actual figure might be twice of that.
IV. On Racial
Discrimination
Racial discrimination has been deeply rooted in the United States,
permeating into every aspects of society.
The colored people are generally poor, with living condition much
worse than the white. According to a report of The Guardian of Britain
on Oct. 9, 2004, the average net assets of a white family is 88,000 US
dollars in 2002, 11 times of a family of Latin American ancestry, or
nearly 15 times of a family of African ancestry. Nearly one third of
the African ancestry families and 26 percent of the Latin American
ancestry families have negative net assets. 74 percent of the white
families have their own houses, while only 47 percent of families of
the African and Latin American ancestry have their own houses. The
market value of houses bought by black families is only 65 percent of
those of white people. Black people's encounter of mortgage loans
refusal for house purchase or furniture is twice that of white people.
Some black families don't even think of buying their own houses. The
death rate of illness, accident and murder among the black people is
twice that of the white.
The rate of being victim of murders for the black people is five times
that of the white. The rate of being affected by AIDS for the black
people is ten times that of the whites while the rate of being
diagnosed by diabetes for the black people is twice that of the
whites. (The State Of Black America 2004, Issued by National Urban
League on March 24, 2004, http://www.nuL.org/pdf/sobaexec.pdf).
Statistics show that the number of black people living in poverty is
three times that of the white. The average life expectancy of the
black is six years shorter than the white.
People of minority ethnic groups are biased against in employment and
occupation. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission of the United
States received 29,000 complaints in 2003 of racial bias in the
workplace (Racism in the 21st Century, published in USA Today May 5,
2004 issue).
Statistics provided by the United States Department of Labor also
suggest that by November 2004, the unemployment rate for black and
white people is 10.8 percent and 4.7 percent respectively (http://bls.gov/news.release/pdf/empsit.pdf).
In New York City, one of every two black men between 16 and 64 was not
working by 2003 (see Nearly Half of Black Men Found Jobless, published
by The New York Times on Feb. 28 2004). Black people not only have
fewer job opportunities, but also earn less than white people. Even
with the same job, a black man only earns 70 percent of that for a
white man. Regions such as California, where immigrants make up a
larger proportion of the local population, are almost like traps of
death. Mexican Laborers who have come to work in the United States
have a mortality as high as 80 percent.
Teenagers from at least 38 countries work like slaves (EFE San
Francisco, Sept. 26, 2004). Out of 45 million people who are unable to
afford Medicare in the United States, 7 million are African-Americans,
accounting for about one fifth of the total African-Americans in the
States. The proportion is 77 percent higher than that for the white
people (available at http://www.johnkerry.com/communities/african-americans/gw_record.html).
The Declaration of Independence said all men are created equal, so the
gap between black and white people is simply an insult to the founding
essence of the United States (see US News and World Report on March
29, 2004).
Apartheid runs rampant at schools of the United States. On May 17,
1954, Chief justice Earl Warren of the Supreme Court announced the
court's decision over a case known as Brown v. Board of Education that
the doctrine of "separate but equal" had no place in US public
schools. Fifty years later, white children and black children in the
United States still lead largely separate lives. One in eight southern
black students attends a school that is 99 percent black. About a
third attend schools that are at least 90 percent minority. In the
Northeast, by contrast, more than half of blacks attend such schools
(Schools and Lives Are Still Separate, The Washington Post, May 17,
2004).
Racism recurs on campus of American universities. Fascist slogans and
posters promoting superiority of white people, along with threats by
weapon or words were found on college campuses including University of
California at Berkeley. Protests were sparked off when Santa Rosa
Junior College in California published anti-Semitism opinions in a
column article in its campus newspaper and the chat room of its
website were dominated by white-superior surfers. At Dartmouth
College, white girl students auctioned off black slaves in
fund-raising activities. At the University of Southern Mississippi,
hordes of white students assaulted four black students, chanting
racist slogans after a football match was over. At Olivet College of
Michigan State, where there are only 55 black students, 51 of the
black students quitted school after racial cases of violence or
harassment (see The China Press, a Chinese language newspaper
published in New York, on April 17, 2004).
Racial prejudice has made social conflicts to become acute, causing a
rise in hate crimes. Racial prejudice, most often directed at black
people, was behind more than half of the nation's 7,489 reported hate
crime incidents in 2003, the FBI said on Nov.22 2004. Race bias was
behind 3,844 of the total cases in 2003, FBI claimed after having made
statistics of hate crimes handled by 16 percent of the law-enforcement
organizations in the States.
Reports of hate crimes motivated by anti-black bias totaled 2,548 in
2003, accounting for 51.4 percent of the total, more than double the
total hate crimes against all other racial groups. There were 3,150
black victims in these reports, according to the annual FBI figures
(AP, Washington, Jan. 26, 2004). And with regard to the attribute of
race, among the 6,934 reported offenders, 62.3 percent were white
(http:/www.fbi.gov/pressrel/presssrel04/pressel/12204.htm).
In
a related development, because of the "lingering atmosphere of fear"
stemming from the Sept. 11 attacks and fallout from the Iraq War,
there were 1,019 anti-Muslim incidents in the United States in 2003,
representing a 69 percent increase. There were 221 incidents in 2003
of anti-muslim bias in California, tripled a year ago (Los Angeles
Times, May 3).
Racial prejudice is ubiquitous in judicial fields. The proportion for
persons of colored races being sentenced or being imprisoned is
notably higher than whites. In accordance with a report published in
November 2004 by the US Department of Justice, colored races accounted
for over 70 percent of inmates in the United States. And 29 percent of
black people have the experience of being in jail for once. Black
people make up 12.3 percent of the population in the United States,
but by the end of 2003, out of 1.4 million prisoners who are serving
jail terms above one year at the federal or state prisons, 44 percent
were blacks, or on average, 3,231 in every 100,000 African-Americans
were criminals. Latino-American inmates make up 19 percent of the
total prisoners, or 1,778 in every 100,000 Latino-Americans are
inmates. Inmates of other color races account for 21 percent (http://wwww.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/abstract/P03.htm).
At the end of 2003, 12.8 percent of black men aged 25 to 29 were in
prison (Chicago Tribune, Nov. 8, 2004), compared 1.6 percent of white
men in the same group (A Growing Need for Reform, The Baltimore Sun,
June 20, 2004). Blacks receive, on average, a longer felony sentence
than whites. A black person's average jail sentence is six months
longer than a white's for the same crime. Blacks who are arrested are
3 times more likely to be imprisoned than whites who are arrested.
White felons are more likely to get probation than blacks. (see the
State Black America 2004, issued by National Urban League on March 24,
2004, http://www.nul.org/pdf/sobaexec.pdf).
After the Sept. 11 incident, the United States openly restricts the
rights of citizens under the cloak of homeland security, and uses
diverse means including wire tapping of phone conversations and secret
investigations, checks on all secret files, and monitoring transfers
of fund and cash flows to supervise activities of its citizens, in
which, people of ethnic minority groups, foreigners and immigrants
become main victims.
Statistics show that after the Sept. 11 attacks, 32 million were
investigated out of racial prejudice concern throughout the United
States. Among the people being investigated out of racial prejudice
concern, African-Americans made up 47 percent, followed by people of
Latino and Asian origins. White Americans only account for 3 percent.
On June 23, 2004, authorities with the Los Angeles Police Department
and the US Federal Bureau of Investigation authorities investigated
the televised beating of a black suspect by white police in Los
Angeles that has resurrected the explosive spectre of the 1991 Rodney
King assault. Eight police officers have been removed from regular
duties following the incident on June 23 in which three of them were
seen tackling the suspected black car thief, one beating him
repeatedly with a metal flashlight (AFP, Los Angeles, June 24, 2004).
In
the meantime, the anti-immigrant trend has become increasingly serious
in the States. The US Department of Homeland Security announced in
November 2004 that 157,281 immigrants were repatriated in one year, up
8 percent from a year ago, a record high. The number of foreigners
arrested without any documents also went up by 112 percent (Argentina
La Nacion, Nov. 21, 2004).
Another report says starting from last year, many American cities such
as San Francisco, Baltimore, Philadelphia, Miami, Saint Paul, Denver,
Kansas and Portland, dozens of immigrants from Mexico or other
countries are arrested each day and are forced to wear fetters like
suspects. The practice of treating illegal immigrants like criminals
has become a national trend. The limit in the definition of terrorists
and illegal immigrants has become very blurry.
V. On The Rights
of Women and Children
The situation of American women and children was disturbing. The rates
of women and children physically or sexually victimized were high.
According to FBI Crime Statistics, in 2003 the United States witnessed
93,233 cases of raping. Virtually 63.2 in every 100,000 women fell
victims. The statistics also showed that every two minutes one woman
was sexually assaulted and every six minutes one woman was raped.
The number of women abused and treated at First Aid Centers exceeded
one million every year. More than 1,500 women in the United States
were killed every year by their husbands, lovers or roommates (The
Milenio, Mexico, Sept. 26, 2004). Nearly 78 percent of American women
were physically victimized at least once in their lifetime. And 79
percent of the women were sexually abused at least once. A survey
released in November 2004 by the US National Institute of Justice
showed by the time they concluded four years of college education, 88
percent of the women had experiences of physical or sexual
victimization and 64 percent of them experienced both. In the past
decade, charges handled by the US Equal Employment Opportunity
Commission against sexual harassment on women surged 22 percent (The
Sun, Jul. 16, 2004).
Sex crimes in the US military were on the rise. According to the
Washington Post (Jun. 3, 2004), from 1999 to 2002 the number of
lawsuits against sexual crimes in the US army that were formally filed
grew from 658 to 783, up 19 percent. And the number of rape cases went
up from 356 to 445, up 25 percent. The number of such cases rose
equally 5 percent between 2002 and 2003. The British Guardian reported
on Oct. 25, 2004 that by the end of September 2004 the Miles
Foundation had dealt with 242 cases filed between September 2002 and
August 2003 about US woman soldiers being raped or sexually harassed
in Iraq,
Kuwait,
Bahrain or
Afghanistan. In addition, there were 431 cases of US women
soldiers being sexually harassed at other military bases.
Women's labor and social rights were violated. According to The Sun
newspaper (Jul. 16, 2004), the charges handled by the Equal Employment
Opportunity Commission on sexual discrimination against women grew 12
percent in the past decade. In 2004 two cases drew wide attention.
They were a bias class lawsuit involving 1.6 million women employees
at Wal-Mart and another case involving 340 women staffers of Morgan
Stanley (New York Times, Jul. 13, 2004).
Men and women on the same job were not paid the same. Statistics
released by the US Labor Department in Jan. 2004 showed a woman who
worked full time had the median earning of 81.1 percent of that for a
man. The Chicago Tribune said on Aug. 27, 2004 that the rate of women
in poverty went up fast, to 12.4 percent of the entire female
population.
The health care for American women was at a low level. The US Family
Medical Leave Act guarantees 12 weeks of unpaid leave for childbirth
to about half of all mothers and nothing for the rest. A study of 168
countries conducted by the Harvard School of Public Health indicated
that US workers have fewer rights to time off for family matters than
workers in most other countries, and rank near the bottom in pregnancy
and sick leave. "The United States trails enormously far behind the
rest of the world when it comes to legislation to protect the health
and welfare of working families," said Jody Heymann, a Harvard
associate professor who led the study. (AP Boston, Jun. 17, 2004)
Child poverty was a serious problem. The Chicago Tribune reported on
Aug. 27, 2004 that the number of children in poverty climbed from 12.1
million in 2002 to 12.9 million in 2003, a year-on-year increase of
0.9 percent. About 20 million children lived in "low-income working
families" -- with barely enough money to cover basic needs (AP
Washington, Oct. 12, 2004). In California, one in every six children
did not have medical insurance. The Los Angeles Times said on May 6,
2004 that in the metropolitan area the number of homeless children
found wondering on the streets at nights numbered 8,000, which had
stretched the 2,500-bed government-run emergency shelter system well
beyond capacity. Poverty deprived many children the opportunity to
obtain higher education. In the 146 renowned institutions of higher
learning, only 3 percent of the students came from the low-income
class, while 74 percent of them were from the high-income class.
Children were victims of sex crimes. Every year about 400,000 children
in the US were forced to engage in prostitution or other sexual
dealings on the streets. Home-deserting or homeless children were the
most likely to fall victims of sexual abuse. Reports on children
sexually exploited, which were received by the National Center for
Missing & Exploited Children, soared from 4,573 cases in 1998 to
81,987 cases in 2003 (The USA Today, Feb. 27,2004).
In
recent years scandals about clergymen molesting children kept breaking
out. According to a study commissioned by the American Catholic
Bishops, in 2004 a total of 756 catholic priests and lay employees
were charged with child sexual harassment. It is believed that from
1950 to 2002 more than 10,600 boys and girls were sexually abused by
nearly 4,400 clergymen (AFP, Feb. 17, 2005). Moreover, every year over
4.5 million kids in the United States were molested in kindergartens
and schools, which amounted to one in every ten (AP, Jul. 14, 2004).
Violent crimes occurred frequently. Studies show nearly 20 percent of
US juveniles lived in families that possessed guns. In Washington D.C.
24 people younger than 18 were killed in 2004, twice as many as in
2003 (The Washington Post, Jan. 1, 2005). In Baltimore, 29 juveniles
were killed from Jan. 1 to Sept. 27 in 2004. In 2003 35 were killed
(The Washington Post, Sept. 28, 2004).
A
report released by the US Justice Department on November 29, 2004 said
about 9 percent of school kids aged 9 to 12 admitted being threatened
with injury or having suffered an injury from a weapon while at school
in 2003.
More and more schoolers were reluctant to go to school because of
security concerns. Child abuses and neglects were widely reported in
the United States. The Sun newspaper reported on May 18, 2004 that in
2002, a total of 900,000 children in the United States were abused, of
whom nearly 1,400 died.
Every year, 1.98 out of every 100,000 American children were killed by
their parents or guardians. In Maryland, the rate was as high as 2.4
per 100,000. (Md Child Abuse Deaths Exceed National Average, The Sun,
May 18, 2004). The Houston Chronicle newspaper reported on Oct. 2,
2004 that in Texas, each staff of local government departments
responsible for protecting children's rights handled 50 child abuse
cases every month.
Two thirds of juvenile detention facilities in the United States lock
up mentally ill youth; every day, about 2,000 youth were incarcerated
simply because community mental health services were unavailable. In
33 states, juvenile detention centers held youth with mental illness
without any specific charges against them (http://demonstrats.reform.house.gov/Documents/200408171941-41051.pdf).
The USA Today reported on July 8, 2004 that between Jan. 1 and June 30
of 2003, 15,000 youth detained in US youth detention centers were
awaiting mental health services, while children at the age of 10 or
younger were locked up in 117 youth detention centers. The detention
centers totally ignored human rights and personal safety with
excessive use of drugs and force, and failed to take care of inmates
with mental problems in a proper way. They even locked up prisoners in
cages. There were reports about scandals involving correctional
authorities in California, where two juvenile inmates hanged
themselves after they were badly beaten by jail police (San Jose
Mercury News and Singtao Daily, March 18, 2004).
VI. On the
Infringement of Human Rights of Foreign Nationals
In
2004, US army service people were reported to have abused and insulted
Iraqi POWs, which stunned the whole world. The US forces were blamed
for their fierce and dirty treatments for these Iraqi POWs. They made
the POWs naked by force, masking their heads with underwear (even
women's underwear), locking up their necks with a belt, towing them
over the ground, letting military dogs bite them, beating them with a
whip, shocking them with electric batons, needling them sometimes, and
putting chemical fluids containing phosphorus on their wounds. They
even forced some of the these POWs to play "human-body pyramid" while
staying naked, in the presence of US soldiers who were standing on the
roof and mocking at them. They sometimes sodomized these POWs with
lamp pipes and brooms. Some Iraqi civilians were also fiercely abused.
The newspaper Pyramid pointed out that the true face of Americans was
exposed through this incident. A spokesman of the International
Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) said, sarcastically, that the US has
made the whole world see what the hell a democratic, law-ruled nation
is.
According to US media like the Newsweek and the Washington Post, as
early as several years ago, in US forces' prisons in Afghanistan,
interrogators used various kinds of torture tools for acquiring
confession, causing many deaths.
British newspaper The Observer reported on March 14, 2004 that
according to a report by the ICRC, US soldiers had formed a kind of
mode for arresting people even before the Iraq war. "Torture is part
of the process."
Over 100 former Iraqi high-ranking government and military officials
were put under special custody by the US military. They stayed 23
hours a day in dark, small and tightly closed concrete-made wards,
where they were allowed to leave the wards twice a day, with 20
minutes available for taking a bath or going to the toilet.
On
Nov. 26, Iraqi Lieutenant General Abid Hamid Mahmud al-Tikriti was put
in a sleeping bag by force and died after he was physically tortured
during an interrogation.
According to a latest report by AP, on Feb. 18, 2005, in November
2003, CIA people hanged dead one of the so-called "ghost" prisoner in
the Abu Ghraib Prison by fierce means, with his two hands cuffed
behind his back. When he was released with shackles and lowered, blood
gushed from his mouth "as if a faucet had been turned on."
Among the 94 abuse cases confirmed and published by the Office of the
US Inspector General for the Filed Army, 39 people were killed, 20 of
these cases were confirmed as murder. There were also severe child
abuses conducted by the US forces.
At
least 107 children were imprisoned in seven prisons including the Abu
Ghraib Prison run by the US forces in Afghanistan. They were not
allowed to get in contact with their families. Their term in prison
was undetermined. It was not clear when they were going to be brought
court hearing. Some of these children had been abused. One low-ranking
US officer who had served in the Abu Ghraib Prison testified that US
soldiers abused some of these children in custody, and they had even
assaulted young girls sexually.
What's more fierce is that US soldiers used military dogs to frighten
these juvenile prisoners to see whose dog could scare them to lose
control on excretion. US forces had violated the Vienna Convention on
Diplomatic Relations, by detaining two Palestinian diplomats to Iraq
in a prison ward of the Abu Ghraib Prison, together with 90 other men.
They spent one year in the prison, suffering from very poor living
conditions.
The ICRC believed that abuse of detained Iraqis in the notorious Abu
Ghraib Prison was not a single case. It was a systematic behavior.
According to some White House documents that were made public on June
22, 2004, the Department of Defense approved to use harsh means to
interrogate prisoners in Guantanamo, Cuba.
The US Secretary of Defense said in the public that the Geneva
Convention does not mean that all the detainees, especially those who
were so-called "non-fighting personnel", should be treated as a POW. A
draft memorandum of the Department of Defense also claimed that US
laws and international conventions, including the Geneva Convention,
which strictly ban the use of torture, do not apply to US President as
the General Commander of the US Army. A memorandum of the US
Department of Justice makes it even more clearly that the United
States could use international laws to measure other countries on the
issue of the treatment of POWs, while it is not necessary for
Washington to abide by these laws. The interrogators were trained to
find ways to torture prisoners, physically, while they should exceed
the Geneva Convention, technically.
Media found that the US soldiers' behaviors in humiliating Iraqi
prisoners as showed photos were typically what they were trained for.
US Brigadier General Yanis Karpinski told the press that her boss once
said to her that "prisoners are dogs." If they were made to think that
they were a bit better than dogs, they could get out of control.
Meanwhile, the US government has tried for the third successive year
to extend the term of a resolution of the UN Security Council that
soldiers could be exempted of lawsuit by the International Criminal
Court, even if they break the relevant rules. In view of prisoner
abuses in Iraq, this has been strongly criticized by the UN General
Secretary (Reuters' story on June 17,2004).
Former US President Jimmy Carter also criticized that the US policies
formulated by the high-ranking officials are a kind of retrogression,
which has damaged the principles of democracy and rule of law and
lacked respect for fundamental human rights.
To
avoid international scrutiny, the United States keeps under wraps half
of its 20-odd detention centers worldwide which are holding terrorist
suspects. And at least seven US-controlled clandestine prisons, one of
which dubbed "inferno," in Afghanistan, have not been kept within the
bounds of law. (Prensa Latina, Aug. 16, 2004)
In
a report by the Human Rights First on 24 US secret interrogation
centers, these secret facilities are believed to "make inappropriate
detention and abuse not only likely but virtually inevitable."
(British newspaper the Times, Sept. 11, 2004)
Moreover, an executive jet is being used by the American intelligence
agencies to fly terrorist suspects to other countries, in a bid to use
torture and evade American laws. The plane is leased by the US Defense
Department and the CIA from a private company in Massachusetts. Being
accused of making so-called "torture flights," the jet has conducted
more than 300 flights and has flown to 49 destinations outside the
United States, including the Guantanamo Bay prison camp in Cuba. The
suspects are frequently bound, gagged and sedated before being put on
board the plane (British newspaper the Times, Nov. 14, 2004). The
United States has secretly shifted thousands of captives worldwide in
the past three years, most of whom were not indicted officially.
The United States is the No. 1 military power in the world, and its
military spending has kept shooting up. Its fiscal 2005 defense budget
hit a historical high of 422 billion US dollars, an increase of 21
billion dollars over fiscal 2004. As the biggest arms dealer in the
world, the United States has made a fortune out of war. Its
transactions of conventional weapons exceeded 14.5 billion dollars in
2003, up 900 million dollars year-on-year and accounting for 56.7
percent of the total sales worldwide. The Iraq War has been "a helping
straw" to the US economic development.
The United States frequently commits wanton slaughters during external
invasions and military attacks. Spain's Uprising newspaper on May, 12,
2004 published a list of human rights infringement incidents committed
by the US troops, quoting two bloodthirsty sayings of two American
generals, "The only good
Indians I ever saw were dead" by General Philip Sheridan and "we
should bomb
Vietnam back to the stone age" by air force general Curtis LeMay.
We can still smell a similar bloodiness in the Iraq War waged by the
United States.
Statistics from the health department of the interim Iraqi government
show 3,487 people, including 328 women and children, have been killed
and another 13,720 injured in 15 of Iraq's 18 provinces between April
15 and Sept. 19 in 2004.
A
survey on Iraqi civilian deaths, based on the natural death rate
before the war, estimates that the US-led invasion might have led to
100,000 more deaths in the country, with most victims being women and
children.
Jointly designed and conducted by researchers at Johns Hopkins
University, Columbia University and the Al-Mustansiriya University in
Baghdad, the survey also finds that the majority of the additional,
unnatural deaths since the invasion were caused by violence, while air
strikes from the coalition forces were the main factor to blame for
the violence-caused deaths. (Associated Press, Oct. 28, 2004)
On
Jan. 3, 2004, four US soldiers stationed in Iraq pushed two Iraqi
civilians into the Tigris River, making one of them drowned.
On
May 19, 2004, an American helicopter fired on a wedding party in a
remote Iraqi village close to the
Syrian border, killing 45 people, including 15 children and 10
women. On Nov. 20, 2004, seven people were killed in Ramadi in the
Anbar province when US troops opened fire on a civilian bus.
According to a Staff Sergeant in the US Marines, his platoon killed 30
civilians in six weeks. And he has witnessed the blasphemy and gradual
rotting of many corpses, and a lot of wounded civilians were deserted
without any medical treatment. (British newspaper The Independent, May
23, 2004)
In
addition, the US troops often plunder Iraqi households when tracking
down anti-US militants since the invasion. The American forces has so
far committed at least thousands of robberies and 90 percent of the
Iraqis that have been rummaged are innocent.
The United States has been hindering the work of the United Nation's
human rights mechanism. And it either took no notice of or used
delaying tactics on the requests of relevant UN agencies to visit its
Guantanamo Bay prison camp in Cuba.
Some justice-upholding developing countries introduced draft
resolutions on America's democracy and human rights situation to the
59th UN General Assembly, to show their strong concern over the US
human rights infringement, prisoner abuse, media control, and
loopholes in its election system.
It
is the common goal and obligation for all countries in the world to
promote and safeguard human rights. No country in the world can claim
itself as perfect and has no room for improvement in the human rights
area. And no country should exclude itself from the international
human rights development process, or view itself as the incarnation of
human rights which can reign over other countries and give orders to
the others. Even the United States shall be no exception.
Despite tons of problems in its own human rights, the United States
continues to stick to its belligerent stance, wantonly trample on the
sovereignty of other countries, and constantly stage tragedies of
human rights infringement in the world.
Instead of indulging itself in publishing the "human rights country
report" to censure other countries unreasonably, the United States
should reflect on its erroneous behavior on human rights and take its
own human rights problems seriously. The double standards of the
United States on human rights and its exercise of hegemonism and power
politics under the pretext of promoting human rights will certainly
put itself in an isolated and passive position and beget opposition
from all just members of the international community. |